Dark Souls III vs Half-Life: Alyx

Verdict

Dark Souls III is the longer game by about 32 hours on a typical playthrough (47h vs 15h for Half-Life: Alyx).

If you only have time for one and prefer a tighter experience, Half-Life: Alyx wraps up faster. If you want the longer ride, go with Dark Souls III.

For completionists, Dark Souls III clocks in at 97 hours total, while Half-Life: Alyx sits at 21 hours.