Elden Ring vs Red Dead Redemption 2

Verdict

Elden Ring is the longer game by about 16 hours on a typical playthrough (99h vs 83h for Red Dead Redemption 2).

If you only have time for one and prefer a tighter experience, Red Dead Redemption 2 wraps up faster. If you want the longer ride, go with Elden Ring.

For completionists, Elden Ring clocks in at 134 hours total, while Red Dead Redemption 2 sits at 182 hours.